Supreme Court Judgments
The judgements of the Supreme Court of India are given for reference, sortable by date, judge, section/rule, IPC section etc. The amendments of 2016 has created a mess in the referencing since the numbering in Section 3 has been changed. There is avoidable confusion regarding Sections, for instance Section 3(1)(i) – does it mean the Roman numeral (original Act) or the English alphabet (2016 amendment)? Some judges have taken to using Arabic numerals in place of the Roman [so Section 3(1)(15) by Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah and Hima Kholi], or referring to the original numbers as Section 3(3) [So Section 3(3)(10) by Justice L Nageswara Rao].
These are innovative workarounds what is essentially poor craft by the union government. Till such time there is a common standard of reference, we will use the contemporary numbering format. The reader is advised caution in interpreting the sections. As a general rule, the sections invoked for crimes committed before 26 January 2016 will be using the original numbering format.
Feedback is welcome on better ways of organising this data.
Volunteers are requested for acquiring similar data from the high courts.
We will update on the new section numbering for the BS laws once the supremes weigh in on a case which uses it.
wdt_ID | Appeal Type | Appeal No | Appeal Year | Appellant | Respondents | IPC | PoA | Judgment Date | Judgment by | Judgement | View |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Criminal | 40 | 1998 | Kumuch Lal | State of Uttar Pradesh | 3(2)(v) | 31/03/1999 | Nanavati | Convicted (upheld) | View | |
2 | Criminal | 94 | 2000 | Gangula Ashok | State of Andhra Pradesh | 3(1)(xi) 14 | 28/01/2000 | K.T. Thomas & M.B.Shah | Appeal dismissed | View | |
3 | Criminal | 297 | 2001 | State of Maharashtra | Ritesh S/o Vasudeo Wanjari | 3(1)(xi) | 15/03/2001 | Sethi | Appeal sustained | View | |
4 | Criminal | 1299-1300 | 2002 | Malkhansingh | State of Madhya Pradesh | 3(1)(x) | 07/08/2003 | Singh, BP | Appeal dismissed | View | |
5 | Criminal | 450 | 1997 | Kuttappan M A | Krishnan Nayanar and another. E | 3(1)(x) | 26/02/2004 | Singh, BP | Appeal dismissed | View | |
6 | Criminal | 730 | 1998 | Moly and Anr. | State of Kerala | 3(1)(iii), 3(1)(v), 3(1)(x) 14 | 23/03/2004 | Pasayat, Arijit | Appeal dismissed | View | |
7 | Criminal | 1312 | 2005 | State of Madhya Pradesh | Dayanand Dohar | 3(1)(xi) | 10/06/2005 | Mathur, GP | Remanded back to the High Court for a fresh hearing. | View | |
8 | Criminal | 1285 | 2005 | State of Madhya Pradesh | Gauri Shankar | 3(1)(xi) | 04/10/2005 | Mathur, GP | Remanded back to the High Court for a fresh hearing. | View | |
10 | Criminal | 263 | 2006 | Dinesh @ Buddha | State of Rajasthan | 376(2) | 3(2)(v) | 28/02/2006 | Pasayat, Arijit; Kapadia, SH | Acquitted of POA; Sentence reduced to 10 years from life. | View |
11 | Criminal | 1156-1158 | 2005 | Ramdas | State of Maharashtra | 3(2)(v) | 11/07/2006 | Singh, BP | Acquitted | View | |
12 | Criminal | 303 | 2006 | Rajbir Singh | State of Uttar Pradesh | 3(2)(v) | 03/08/2006 | Mathur, GP | Appeal sustained | View | |
13 | Criminal | 971 | 2006 | Suga Ram @ Chhuga Ram | State of Rajasthan & Ors. | 3(2) | 18/09/2006 | Pasayat, Arijit | Appeal partially allowed | View | |
14 | Criminal | 934 | 2002 | State of Uttar Pradesh | Surendra Kumar Solanki | 3(2) | 21/06/2007 | Pasayat, Dr. Arijit | Apppeal sustained | View | |
15 | Criminal | 1003 | 2007 | Shaik Mastan Vali | State of Andra Pradesh | 3(2)(v) | 08/08/2007 | Pasayat, Dr. Arijit | Appeal dismissed | View | |
18 | Criminal | 1092 | 2008 | Moti Lal | State of Madhya Pradesh | 450, 376(1) | 3(1)(xii) 3 | 15/07/2008 | Pasayat, Dr. Arijit Sathasivam, P | Conviction upheld (Appeal dismissed) | View |
19 | Criminal | 1287 | 2008 | Swaran Singh | State through Standing Counsel & Anr. (Delhi) | 3(1)(x) | 18/08/2008 | Katju, Markandey | Trial to continue under the Act (Apellant one's appeal has been sustained, appellant 2 and 3 are dismissed) | View | |
20 | Criminal | 1311 | 2008 | Gorige Pentaiah | State of Andra Pradesh | 3(1)(x) | 20/08/2008 | Bhandari, Dalveer | Appeal partially allowed | View | |
21 | Criminal | 1493 | 2008 | Daulatram S/o Sadram Teli | State Of Chhattisgarh | 3(2)(v) | 19/09/2008 | Pasayat, Dr. Arijit | Appeal dismissed | View | |
22 | Criminal | 1965 | 2010 | Ram Ratan | State of Rajasthan | 307, 326 and 324 | 3(2)(v) | 08/10/2008 | Alam, Aftab | Appeal sustained | View |
23 | Criminal | 1660 | 2008 | Sonu Kumar | State of Himachal Pradesh | 3(1)(x) | 22/10/2008 | Pasayat, Dr. Arijit | Appeal sustained | View | |
24 | Criminal | 1967 | 2008 | Kashiben Chhaganbhai Koli | State of Gujarat | 3(1)(v) | 04/12/2008 | Pasayat, Dr. Arijit | Convicted | View | |
25 | Criminal | 4833 | 2008 | State of Orissa | Sukru Gouda | 3 to 5 | 16/12/2008 | Pasayat, Dr. Arijit | Appeal dismissed | View | |
26 | Criminal | 38 | 2007 | Jagebar Ali @ Settu | State of Tamil Nadu | 3(2)(v) | 20/01/2009 | Pasayat, Dr. Arijit | Appeal dismissed | View | |
27 | Criminal | 287 | 2009 | Ashabai Machindra Adhagale | State of Maharashtra | 3(1)(xi) | 12/02/2009 | Pasayat, Dr. Arijit | Appeal sustained | View | |
28 | Criminal | 405 | 2009 | Lunaram | Bhupat Singh and Ors. | 3(2)(v) | 27/02/2009 | Pasayat, Dr. Arijit | Appeal dismissed | View |